
I've just recieved an email from Nissenbaum,
Yedda's CEO, asking me to review their product, that is now and finaly in a public beta.
The tagline of Yedda is "Connecting people looking for knowledge with people who have the knowledge", and it's quite self-explaining (as a tagline should be) of what Yedda purposes to do for you: a social network that will connect you to those who have the answers for your questions and the questions for your answers. So, their smaller tagline is just "People. Sharing. Knowledge.". When I've first been introduced to Yedda's concept that was the only thing I knew about it, so I've just wondered if this was an improoved system to do what
Lazyweb does, or if it intends to do something different. It all sounded like "a vague idea turned into a product", which is almost completely sinonymous of "yet another useless web 2.0 app". But the way the issue was spoken about shown nothing of that, so I just wanted to give it a try - maybe they thought of something I didn't.
So, up to registring, And the first negative point right there: an usabillity issue that many webapps have because they just do, without even knowing why. It sucks, pisses off some of their users (like me, whose default login in everything web is "Mind Booster Noori") and that could be fixed with about no cost at all. This message "Username must be 3-20 characters long and contain only Alphanumeric characters (a-z, A-Z, 0-9)" tells me that I can't go with "Mind Booster Noori" or even "Mind_Booster_Noori": I'll have to go with MindBoosterNoori. Of course this is a far from critical issue, but then, it could be easilly fixed.
After registing and trying it for a while I have reached some conclusions. First of all, this app lacks originality. Which wouldn't mean it is a bad choice if it had something innovative, but since it hasn't, you can't just expect to compete with those apps that have already a user-base. The application is preety well designed and implemented - a good piece of software, but it seems quite useless to me: there's nothing making people going there but to ask questions, and there's no incentive at all to make people answering the existing questions. Testing, I've posted a question there, and I'll probably just come back there when I get an email telling me I have new answers to it - there's nothing there making me wanting to come back there.
One another bad issue on Yedda is the fact that their e-mails are considered junk by my spam filter (unpersonalized), which means that many people won't recieve their e-mails. Try to cut down on the use of external links and HTML to fix that.

Yedda can't compete with applications like
Adoppt, that do what Yedda does, but as an "extra feature" to the whole application, that gives you a social network inluding blogging, bookmarks, forums, claim blog, ping and simple Q&A using tags.
All in all, I don't really think that this is a good application - sorry Nissenbaum, but if you want to win in the Web 2.0 world you have to be more than technichly good - you have to have good ideas for your application. Yet, if you (reader) like the concept behind this application, you may want to still try it, or one of the big load of other applications that do the same, like we can see in
this article.